| 
													 
													
													
													1-WITNESS 
													VIDEO CLIP ALLEGEDLY JENI 
													WEINBERGER 
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													2-WITNESS 
													VIDEO CLIP  ALLEGEDLY 
													TASMIN  SILLENCE  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													3-WITNESS 
													VIDEO CLIP  ALLEGEDLY 
													DEREK FLACK
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													4-WITNESS 
													VIDEO CLIP  JANE TANNER  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													5-WITNESS 
													VIDEO CLIP  ALLEGEDLY 
													THE SMITH FAMILY  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													APPENDICES VI VOLUMES 1-5  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													TIMELINE  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													THE MAKING OF CUTTING EDGE 
													IN PORTUGAL  | 
												 
								
													
													
													
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													
													
													
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													
													
													
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													
													
													
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													
													
													
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													
													
													
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													Susan Hubbard wife of Rev 
													Hubbard on location for 
													cutting edge 06.April 2009  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													 Susan Hubbard for cutting 
													edge April 2009  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													Lisa Donovan. American 
													actress who plays Kate  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													|   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													|   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													|   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													|   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													Arthur Cowley 
													and Dave Edgar have reviewed 
													30,000 files released by the 
													Portuguese authorities  
													and 
													think they uncovered vital 
													new evidence
													Photo: 
													(PA: Channel 4 Television)
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													  | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													   | 
												 
								
													| 
													 
													
													
													Transcript - Cutting Edge  
													Thanks to Mitts  | 
												 
								
													
													
													First Section 
													 
													Because of the length of 
													this, I’ll need to split it 
													up and post it in sections. 
													I don’t want it all to 
													disappear, before I hit the 
													“submit” button. 
													 
													I have used abbreviations 
													for everyone’s name. 
													 
													I have not included a 
													transcription of the 
													interaction with the 
													children. It’s so obviously 
													staged. If anyone 
													particularly wants those 
													bits, then PM me and I’ll 
													send them. Also, I have not 
													included the excerpt from 
													the Oprah show. (Stevo, 
													kindly did a full transcript 
													of this) 
													 
													 
													K: I did my check about 
													10.00 ‘clock and went in 
													through the sliding patio 
													doors and I just stood, 
													actually and I thought, oh, 
													all quiet, and to be honest, 
													I might have been tempted to 
													turn round then, but I just 
													noticed that the door, the 
													bedroom door where the three 
													children were sleeping, was 
													open much further than we’d 
													left it. I went to close it 
													to about here and then as I 
													got to here, it suddenly 
													slammed and then as I opened 
													it, it was then that I just 
													thought, I’ll just look at 
													the children and I could see 
													S and A in the cot and then 
													I was looking at M’s bed 
													which was here and it was 
													dark and I was looking and I 
													was thinking, is that M or 
													is that the bedding. and I 
													couldn’t quite make her out. 
													It sounds really stupid now, 
													but at the time, I was 
													thinking I didn’t want to 
													put the light on cos I 
													didn’t wanna wake them and 
													literally, as I went back 
													in, the curtains of the 
													bedroom which were drawn,… 
													were closed, … whoosh … It 
													was like a gust of wind, 
													kinda, just blew them open 
													and cuddle cat was still 
													there and her pink blanket 
													was still there and then I 
													knew straight away that she 
													had, er, been taken, you 
													know. 
													 
													Voice over: It’s now 2 years 
													since MM was abducted while 
													on holiday in Portugal. Her 
													parents, K&G live near L 
													with M’s brother and sister, 
													four year old twins, S&A. 
													 
													G: We are a family, and 
													we’re a happy family, but we 
													are not a complete family. 
													 
													KM: I think we’re far from 
													normality. We’re far from 
													normality but we’re closer 
													than we were. 
													 
													K is painting the names of 
													the three children. 
													She asks the children what 
													is the name of their sister. 
													One of the children says the 
													full name and the other 
													child says the shortened 
													version. 
													 
													K: I honestly believe 
													they’re expecting her to 
													come home, you know, one day 
													soon. They are very much, 
													well, when Madeleine comes 
													back, we’ll share our toys 
													and, you know, A is wearing 
													Madeleine’s shoes. She’ll 
													say well these shoes won’t 
													fit M, now, so we’ll have to 
													take her and get her a 
													bigger pair of shoes when 
													she gets home. You know. 
													 
													Voice over: K has given up 
													her work as a GP and now 
													stays at home with the 
													twins. 
													 
													K: A lot of the places that 
													I go now ,I used to go with 
													Madeleine as well, so 
													there’s little things that 
													trigger, (mumble) like on 
													the farm where we go quite a 
													lot. You know, I can see 
													Madeleine swinging on the 
													rope in the hayloft. She was 
													great, she was only three 
													and she’d be like, you know, 
													swinging backwards and 
													forwards, you know. I can 
													see her in the little, sort 
													of, gypsy wagon that they 
													had, asking me to come in 
													and that’s hard. You get 
													memories and reality hits in 
													again. 
													 
													It’s like kinda, of, um, 
													tangible void, really. 
													 
													Voice over: G has returned 
													to work at GH, where he is a 
													consultant cardiologist. 
													 
													G: Given the indefinite 
													nature of what we are going 
													through, you have to, at 
													some point, say, I’m going 
													to go back. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: Do you 
													think you have both healed a 
													bit. 
													 
													G: Healed is a diffi…adapted, 
													I think, is probably the 
													right word. There’s still, 
													there’s a scar, a deep, deep 
													scar there, that’s, kinda, 
													knitted at the minute but 
													you still think it might 
													break or come loose and 
													stitches (mumble) But, it 
													is, er, definitely an er… 
													adaptation. I think. 
													 
													G: There’ll always be a 
													hope, you know, we’re living 
													with this carrot, that 
													potentially she could come 
													back and I think, that makes 
													it more painful, that you 
													don’t know and that she’s, 
													she’s, she’s out there and 
													separated from you It’s less 
													raw, erm, less painful on a 
													day to day basis, erm, but, 
													it’s still pretty painful. 
													(Sighs) Erm, it’s different. 
													 
													Voice over: The second 
													anniversary of M’s 
													disappearance is 
													approaching. K&G want to use 
													the media attention to keep 
													the search in the public’s 
													mind. 
													 
													K: (in their study). It 
													almost feels like the last, 
													I guess, media opportunity. 
													We really need to think 
													about that, to get the right 
													message out. 
													 
													Voice over: (very briefly, 
													showing part of fm (download 
													poster page ). The M’s are 
													organising a series of 
													events aimed at prompting 
													fresh evidence, including a 
													difficult trip back to the 
													holiday resort. 
													 
													Voice over continues: A 
													national TV appearance in 
													the States and perhaps, most 
													crucially a visit to the 
													world’s leading child 
													recovery expert. (shows E 
													A). EA says we truly believe 
													(shows the picture) this is 
													what MM looks like today. 
													Shows new image. 
													 
													G: She’s either out there or 
													she’s not and there’s 
													nothing to say that she’s 
													not out there alive. So it’s 
													simple, she’s out there 
													until proven otherwise. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: Who 
													actually is looking for M at 
													the moment? 
													 
													G: Er, hopefully, lots of 
													people, er, in the general 
													population, but in terms of 
													an investigative strategy, 
													then there’s no law 
													enforcement agency that is 
													proactively doing anything. 
													It’s pretty amazing really. 
													Er, when you think about, 
													it’s a very serious crime 
													and, erm, we’ve got to do 
													it. 
													 
													G: We’re not out making a 
													fuss for the sake of it or 
													to say, things were done 
													badly or could have been 
													done better. That’s not what 
													we’re interested in. We’re 
													not interested in looking 
													back. What we want to do is 
													look forward. 
													 
													Voice over: But there are 
													two men still looking for 
													Madeleine, ex-Detective 
													Inspector DE is the senior 
													Investigating Officer. He 
													works alongside former 
													Detective Sargeant A C. Both 
													are now employed by the fm 
													fund. 
													 
													AC: …given a really good 
													description and what I’ve 
													done is, I’ve made 
													arrangements to go and see 
													him on Tuesday morning. 
													 
													DE: I’ve inherited an 
													investigation which is 18 
													months’ old. It’s a massive 
													investigation. 
													 
													AC: For me, it’s quite 
													simple, whether it be a high 
													profile murder or any 
													investigation. It’s a jigsaw 
													puzzle and it’s just the 
													case of putting little 
													pieces in and that’s what 
													we’re doing. You start at 
													the beginning, you do the 
													basics right and everything 
													else comes together. and 
													that’s what, we, hopefully, 
													we’ve done. 
													 
													DE: One of the hypothesis 
													would be, that it’s the 
													parents that have done it, 
													and it goes without saying, 
													that’s looked at and I’m 
													sure K&G understand that. 
													If, we had any evidence that 
													K&G were involved, we would 
													hand it over to the 
													authorities. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer:: and 
													did you find anything? 
													 
													DE: No, nothing, not a shred 
													of evidence that they were 
													involved. 
													 
													AC: When I had the interview 
													for the job, I made it quite 
													clear that I would only take 
													the job, if it was an 
													independent investigation 
													and if there’s evidence 
													against anybody, no matter 
													who it is, that we give that 
													evidence to the police. 
													 
													Voice of interviewer: Do you 
													work with different theories 
													about what happened? Can you 
													say what you think happened? 
													 
													DE: Well, the abduction 
													theory is the main one that 
													we’re focusing on. If a 
													stranger kills a child or 
													anyone for that matter, they 
													almost, almost always dump 
													the body within a very close 
													proximity of the crime 
													scene. Now this particular 
													area around PdL has been 
													systematically searched. The 
													search was started on the 
													night and continued for 
													weeks and weeks and no 
													body’s been found, so that 
													gives me hope. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: What 
													about if it was dumped in 
													the sea? I mean that’s what 
													most …. 
													 
													DE: That’s always possible 
													of course. But, again, the 
													sea quite often, you know, 
													gives up the bodies. But no 
													bodies have been found. So, 
													I think that abduction is 
													the most likely motive. Most 
													likely done by an individual 
													on their own. Most likely, 
													an individual who has close 
													links with PdL, which is why 
													we focused all our efforts 
													really, or most of our 
													efforts, certainly on PdL. 
													 
													Voice over: Out of the 
													hundreds of witnesses who 
													came forward, only a handful 
													are from the local 
													Portuguese community. These 
													are the people the 
													investigators want to hear 
													from so they plan to return 
													to PdL and reconstruct key 
													events surrounding M’s 
													disappearance. Hoping to 
													provoke a response. 
													 
													K: They used to come and 
													just sit and get a haircut. 
													(laughs). Seems hard to 
													believe it’s actually busier 
													now then it was a year ago. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer:: Has 
													the balance changed, because 
													you’re not working in paid 
													work. You’ve worked for most 
													of your adult life. 
													 
													K: Women adore cooking and 
													washing, anyway don’t they? 
													(laughs) 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: So, 
													yes, that hasn’t changed? 
													 
													K: I don’t think so. It’s 
													funny, cos, you know, going 
													back a few years, if I 
													hadn’t been in paid work, 
													I’d have probably felt, a 
													bit guilty. But, now, what 
													I’m doing is the most 
													important job that I’ll 
													every have to do and I think 
													my work is incredibly 
													valuable. 
													 
													Voice over: When the 
													Portuguese police shelved 
													the case last summer, they 
													released 30,000 case files, 
													K has spent the last six 
													months going through every 
													document. 
													 
													K: The vast bulk of it was 
													in Portuguese. So, we then, 
													had to get it all 
													translated, which probably 
													cost us about £100,000. I 
													don’t believe anybody’s got 
													the motivation that I have 
													and I was desperate to go 
													through this myself, because 
													I knew that I’d be going 
													through it with a fine 
													toothcomb and I have spent 
													months and months and months 
													and months going through it, 
													evenings, weekends. You 
													know, you wanna go through 
													it really, really quickly 
													because I wanted to get all 
													the information I can and 
													know what I can do, to help 
													find her, as quickly as 
													possible. So, obviously, I 
													just worked really hard, 
													just to get through it. 
													Often, you know, police do 
													say the name’s in the files. 
													It was always there, but you 
													just need other bits of 
													information, really, to come 
													in to basically highlight 
													the name. At the moment, 
													there isn’t a big arrow and 
													an astrix (sic) by the name. 
													 
													Voice over: The most likely 
													sighting of M and her 
													abductor was by JT, a friend 
													of the Mc’s. In the files, K 
													believes another witness 
													statement from an Irish 
													family, describes a very 
													similar sighting to JT’s. 
													Less than a mile from the 
													Mc’s apartment. 
													 
													K: The reason why this is 
													significant is, both 
													sightings were given 
													independently. So, when this 
													family gave their statement 
													they weren’t aware of J(T)’s 
													description and there’s 
													actually quite a lot of 
													similarities and it does beg 
													the question, I mean, how 
													many people carry their 
													children on a cold night, 
													not covered, you know. 
													Nothing on their arms, or 
													their feet, no blanket. Now, 
													either there’s been two 
													people carrying children 
													that way, who haven’t come 
													forward to eliminate 
													themselves or potentially 
													they’re related. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: But, 
													you think that child is M? 
													 
													K: I think it’s a good 
													chance it could be M. 
													Certainly, the description 
													there, sounds to me, like M. 
													 
													Voice over: K and the fm 
													campaign co-ordinator travel 
													to the search team’s 
													offices. They want to 
													discuss the details of the 
													upcoming reconstructions and 
													three potentially key 
													witness statements, that all 
													tell of a man hanging around 
													the Mc’s apartment in the 
													days leading up to May 3 
													2007. 
													 
													DE: The most important one, 
													apart, obviously, from Jane, 
													is sighting No. 3, the man 
													in the alleyway at the back 
													of the apartment. No.3 is 
													definitely a very important 
													sighting cos it links them. 
													 
													Voice over: The 
													investigators have examined 
													the statements from the 
													three different witnesses 
													and are now convinced that 
													prior to M’s abduction, the 
													Mc’s were being watched. The 
													team hope this new 
													information will give them 
													the breakthrough they need. 
													 
													DE: You’d think, it’s gotta 
													be the same person, wouldn’t 
													you, really? 
													 
													AC: and all three say he was 
													watching the apartment. 
													 
													DE: We’re here to discuss 
													the pending reconstruction 
													that we want done. 
													 
													K: So, basically, it looks 
													like we’ve got five 
													sightings, really. Two, a 
													man with a child and three, 
													just a suspicious 
													individual. 
													 
													DE: Yeah 
													 
													K: and three, the three with 
													the suspicious, suspicious, 
													of the suspicious (she seems 
													to have developed a stutter) 
													individual, kinda, tie in 
													together. 
													 
													DE: They all tie in 
													together. 
													 
													Fm campaign co-ordinator: 
													They’re all at similar times 
													and place. 
													 
													DE: There’s three in exactly 
													the same location. I don’t 
													know what the Portuguese 
													authorities have done to 
													actually eliminate these 
													people from the enquiry. So, 
													we’ve gotta presume that 
													they haven’t done it and go 
													with that. So, it’s just 
													important, that we actually, 
													we are accurate in what we 
													know and make sure that 
													that’s what we’re going 
													with. No speculation. It’s 
													gotta be the facts that we 
													know and not try to fill in 
													the gaps that we don’t know. 
													 
													K: I mean, I’d like to go 
													back, but not for this, to 
													be honest. It’s kinda, just 
													below the surface and I 
													just, you know, I’d be 
													scared, I think, you know, 
													to sort of open it open it 
													up again, really, so. yeah. 
													I think, it’s actually going 
													through the scenario of that 
													night, as well, you know. 
													Erm, I mean, you know, even 
													what I can remember of the 
													night, you know. Seeing G, 
													erm, that distraught, 
													really, sobbing and on the 
													floor. I mean, I suppose I’m 
													concerned that that will, er, 
													surface again. 
													 
													Voice over: K calls key 
													witness JT, who has agreed 
													to join G and the 
													investigators in PdL for the 
													reconstructions. 
													 
													Scene: K talking on the 
													phone to JT 
													 
													K: “Oh, ok, pretty busy, 
													(she laughs). Although, it’s 
													quite good to be honest to 
													be doing stuff and focused 
													and it just sort of helps, 
													you know, to be doing 
													something positive thing. 
													How you feeling about the 
													weekend? I mean, I’m really 
													nervous and I’m not going 
													(laughs). Thank you very 
													much by the way. No, I know, 
													I know it’s a big step, but 
													we appreciate it anyway so, 
													thank you. 
													 
													K: Er, she’s trying not to 
													think about it. She just 
													said, erm, apart from the 
													obvious emotional concern, 
													she’s worried about the 
													reaction of people locally. 
													 
													Voice over: Returning will 
													be controversial. PdL was a 
													popular family holiday 
													resort, but things haven’t 
													been the same since M’s 
													abduction. 
													 
													K: You know, we are aware 
													that, unfortunately, erm, 
													this has all been a headache 
													really for people whose 
													businesses are out there, 
													their livelihoods, you know. 
													It’s a negative, a child’s 
													been abducted from that area 
													and I guess in the ideal 
													world, it would all go away, 
													you know, everybody could 
													move on with their lives 
													and, but, you know, our 
													little girl is still missing 
													so … 
													 
													K: I think regardless of 
													what anybody thinks of me 
													and G, and I’m a bit past 
													caring now, really. But, you 
													know, I think, people do 
													feel for M and that’s the 
													most important thing and 
													they want M to be found and 
													they want M to be well. 
													There has been a question as 
													to why now and I’d simply 
													say, well M is still 
													missing. Why not, now? You 
													know. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: Do you 
													feel there’s a lot riding on 
													this weekend? 
													 
													K: I do, yeah, and I’m 
													nervous. I’m nervous because 
													I realise how important this 
													is to do really. To get that 
													bit of key information, I’m 
													nervous that it’ll … all 
													could get sabotaged or it 
													could all go very wrong. 
													Obviously, I don’t want that 
													because it’s so important. 
													 
													G: We are desperate for this 
													to be successful and to be 
													done and hopefully it might 
													be one call, t might be 10 
													calls, but that’s all it’ll 
													take, it could be just one 
													piece of information. 
													 
													DE: The offence was 
													committed in PdL, that’s a 
													simple fact. So, you don’t 
													start an investigation in, 
													er, Morocco or Spain or even 
													Lisbon. This event’s 
													happened in PdL. It’s a very 
													self-contained resort and 
													that’s where I think the 
													answer is. 
													 
													Voice over: D E is leading 
													the search for MM. Today, 
													he’s in PdL, on the 
													Portuguese Algarve, to 
													oversee filming of 
													significant events described 
													in witness statements. 
													Statements, which he 
													believes, strongly suggest 
													that someone was watching 
													the Mc family. He hopes that 
													the reconstructions will 
													lead to the discovering who 
													that someone is. 
													 
													DE: He may even have been 
													watching the apartment for a 
													week or more. I don’t think 
													it was someone random. In my 
													experience random just 
													doesn’t happen. Someone just 
													doesn’t go in, … passerby, 
													and pick up a child and take 
													it. These things are 
													planned. 
													 
													DE with Pimpleman actor 
													 
													DE: This, erm, scene. You’re 
													standing over there and 
													you’re standing at an angle 
													 
													Action: filming starts 
													 
													Witness 1: Child and woman 
													walking. 
													 
													Voice over: Witness No. 1 is 
													a British tourist. She first 
													saw something strange four 
													days before M disappeared. 
													 
													Sunday, April 29, approx 
													08.00 
													 
													Witness 1: I was walking 
													along the road with my 
													daughter, when I saw a man. 
													I grabbed my daughter’s hand 
													and pulled her towards me 
													because for some reason, he 
													unnerved me. 
													 
													Voice over: She saw the same 
													man again. This time close 
													to the Mc’s apartment on the 
													day before M went missing 
													 
													Wednesday 2 May approx 15.00 
													 
													Witness 1: The next time I 
													saw him, he was standing on 
													the opposite side of the 
													road to the apartment. He 
													appeared to be watching it. 
													He was about 5’10”, slim 
													build and wearing casual 
													clothes, jeans, I think. I 
													would describe him as very 
													ugly, pitted skin, with a 
													large nose. 
													 
													DE talking to a young girl 
													(Witness 3) 
													 
													DE: …and as you’re just 
													passing here, this chap will 
													be stood over there. So, if 
													you just, you come up, if 
													you just glance over at him 
													and …. 
													 
													Scene shows Witness 2, Mum, 
													girl and two dogs 
													 
													Voice over: The second 
													witness is a school girl, 
													who lives near the holiday 
													complex. Three days before M 
													was taken, she was with her 
													mum outside the M’s 
													apartment. 
													 
													Monday 30 April approx 08.15 
													 
													Witness 2: I was walking to 
													the school bus stop. I go 
													this way to school every 
													day. As I was walking down 
													the road, near the 
													apartment, I saw a man on 
													the small path behind the 
													block. My grandparents used 
													to live in that apartment. 
													So, I always look at it, as 
													I pass by. The man seemed to 
													be looking at the balcony of 
													the ground floor apartment. 
													He was wearing a black 
													jacket and leaning against 
													the wall. 
													 
													Voice over: She saw him 
													again, as well, the day 
													before M was taken. 
													 
													Witness 2: I didn’t go to 
													school that day because I 
													had an ear infection. I was 
													walking up the road with my 
													two dogs, when I saw the 
													man. He was standing on the 
													road opposite the OC and he 
													was staring at the 
													apartment. 
													 
													DE talking to older couple 
													(Witness 3) 
													 
													DE: You have him coming from 
													your apartment, which is 
													over here, somewhere. You 
													turn the corner and walk 
													down the path. 
													 
													Lady witness (the couple) 
													(Witness 3): What the two of 
													us? 
													 
													DE: Yes, the two of you 
													together. 
													 
													DE: This was actually a 
													sketch that was drawn by the 
													witness at the time and, er, 
													as you can see, he’s just 
													stood where we are now. 
													(shows sketch the couple) 
													Make eye contact with him 
													and just walk straight on 
													past. 
													 
													Voice over: Witness No 3 is 
													a man with his partner from 
													Cheshire. He gave a 
													statement to the police 
													describing a man he’d seen 
													near the apartment. 
													 
													Witness 3 (Man) I can’t 
													remember whether I saw the 
													man on Wednesday 2 or 
													Thursday 3 May 
													(approximately 11.30). But 
													as we walked along the road, 
													I saw a man standing next to 
													the wall by the parking 
													area. On the opposite side 
													of the road was a white van. 
													I paid particular attention 
													to him, because he appeared 
													to be focused on watching 
													the apartment block as I 
													walked past him, I looked at 
													him, and for a split second, 
													we had eye contact but then 
													he just carried on staring 
													at the apartment. 
													 
													DE: We’re asking for people 
													to come forward with 
													information. For me, one of 
													the big things in any major 
													crime, the perpetrators 
													always confide in someone 
													else. They’ve gotta get it 
													off their chest and it’s 
													that person, as much as 
													anything, that we’re aiming 
													at. Someone knows something. 
													 
													Voice over: G is back in PdL. 
													His arrival and the 
													reconstructions are 
													attracting a lot of media 
													attention. But for the 
													people who live here, it’s 
													attention they can do 
													without. 
													 
													G: This is an area that 
													relies strongly on tourism 
													and people’s livelihoods 
													have been affected and I can 
													totally understand when 
													people are suffering 
													economically, that they get 
													resentful. But, hope they 
													can understand as well, that 
													as parents, we need to find 
													M. 
													 
													Voice over: The simmering 
													anger is evident. A brand 
													new billboard poster of M 
													with “Help me” in Portuguese 
													has been splattered with 
													paint and at the holiday 
													complex G can hear the 
													hostility (heckling)  
													 
													G: No one, even with a heart 
													of stone, can take away that 
													there’s a little girl 
													missing. Why anyone would 
													not want to help find her is 
													a mystery and obviously if 
													we find M, then everyone can 
													move on. 
													 
													Voice over: He goes back to 
													the Tapas Bar where they ate 
													in the evenings, while the 
													children slept in the 
													apartment. 
													 
													G: I can’t remember exactly 
													where the table was. It was 
													kinda in this bit, so it’d 
													be about around here and I 
													was kinda sitting in this 
													bit and K was here. Well, 
													you could see where the 
													shutters are now and the bit 
													of the hedge, it’s grown. It 
													was cut, you know, a couple 
													of feet lower than that. 
													 
													CONTINUED ....... | 
												 
								
									
						
							
								
									|   | 
								 
								
									
											
												
													
													
													
													Second Section 
													 
													Voice over: For the first 
													time in two years, G returns 
													to apartment 5a of the OC. 
													 
													Voice over: The last place 
													where he saw his daughter, 
													M, asleep in her bed. 
													 
													G: So, I actually came in 
													and M was just at the top of 
													the bed here, where 
													
													I’d 
													left her lying and the 
													covers were folded down and 
													she had her cuddle cat and 
													blanket, were just by her 
													head It’s terrible because, 
													I , erm, had one of those 
													really proud father moments, 
													where I just thought, you 
													know. I just thought, your 
													absolutely beautiful and I 
													love you and I just paused 
													for a minute and then, I 
													just pulled the door closed 
													again and just to about 
													there and, er, I felt 
													incredibly proud standing 
													there and having, you know, 
													3 beautiful children. 
													That’s the, I think the most 
													ironic thing of the lot, 
													that, that momentary pause I 
													had, at that door, that’s 
													exactly what I felt like. 
													You know, a few minutes 
													before our world was 
													essentially shattered and 
													probably, 3 or 4 minutes 
													before M was taken and we 
													obviously, absolutely, er, 
													what’s the word, persecuted 
													ourselves for not being here 
													and, erm, there is no doubt, 
													that not being here at that 
													moment, erm, increased the 
													risk of it. 
													 
													Voice over: The Mc’s were on 
													holiday with a group of 
													friends. In the evenings, 
													they all ate together and 
													took it in turns to make 
													half-hourly checks on each 
													other’s children. Two of the 
													group, MO and JT, both 
													crucial witnesses, have 
													returned to help DE with the 
													reconstructions. It’s 
													believed that M was taken 
													shortly after her father’s 
													check at 9 o’clock. In the 
													45 minutes that followed, 
													there were two significant 
													sightings of a man carrying 
													a young girl. The first was 
													by JT. She was looking in on 
													her sick daughter, when she 
													saw G returning from his 
													check. He was talking to a 
													friend, JW, at the side of 
													the road. However, J(T) and 
													G remember the scene 
													differently. 
													 
													JT: So, I think you were 
													about here. Cos, I think 
													that you were standing like 
													that and, J(W) was there, 
													with his pram, pointing down 
													that way. Cos, I think if 
													you’d been looking at me, I 
													would’ve said something, cos 
													I would’ve said about, cos K 
													had been moaning that you’d 
													been gone a long time 
													watching the football. 
													 
													G: I’m almost certain that 
													when I came out, I came over 
													and he was here and I was 
													like that. That’s my memory 
													of it, it’s like J(W) is 
													6’3” or something and 
													looking up and then turning 
													in, when I finished. That’s 
													my memory of it. 
													 
													JT: Yeah. I mean, well we 
													just ……. 
													 
													DE: It’s like I said, there 
													are, you know, 
													inconsistencies, you know, 
													in every major 
													investigation. 
													 
													JT: Ok, that’s fine. 
													 
													DE: Obviously, the most 
													important thing is what you 
													saw, Jane. It’s not where G 
													and J(W) were actually 
													stood. Because they didn’t 
													obstruct your view of the 
													man. So …. 
													 
													JT: I was walking up here to 
													do the check and probably, 
													as I got to , it’s hard to 
													know exactly where, but 
													probably, about here, I saw 
													the man walk across the road 
													there, carrying the child. I 
													just got up and walked out 
													the Tapas bar, past G 
													talking to J(W). That’s when 
													I saw somebody walk across 
													the top of the road, 
													carrying a child and I 
													think, I did think, oh, 
													there’s somebody taking 
													their child home to bed. 
													But, they didn’t look like a 
													standard tourist. This is 
													ridiculous isn’t it? It just 
													looks so much like somebody 
													abducting a little girl, 
													when you look at it. It just 
													looks so obvious when you 
													know, you know. Just look at 
													it and you think, why the 
													hell didn’t you think there 
													is somebody abducting a 
													child. That was not even a 
													thought, that somebody’s 
													gonna go into an apartment 
													and take a child out. You 
													know, you’re probably the 
													one person that could’ve 
													actually stopped it and you 
													think, oh, what if? It’s 
													that what if? what if?, what 
													if and you can take those 
													what ifs to ad infinitum 
													really. 
													 
													Voice over: At 9.30 pm, half 
													an hour after G’s check it 
													was MO’s turn to look in on 
													all the children. He went 
													into the Mc’s apartment, but 
													didn’t go into the bedroom 
													and so didn’t see if M was 
													missing. 
													 
													MO: Pretty much from the 
													approach down here, you can 
													see straight into the room. 
													So you can see the cots as 
													you are walking in. So it 
													never really felt like there 
													was any real need to, sort 
													of, go all the way into the 
													room. Erm, you could see 
													both cots and see into them 
													from there. I, sort of, 
													ummed and ahed about the 
													angle and things. All I just 
													know is that I had an 
													unimpeded view and it was 
													just dead quiet, and just… 
													why I didn’t take those 
													extra couple of steps in  
													 
													G: Yeah, I mean, I was 
													saying this earlier, that at 
													no point, other than that 
													night, did I go stick my 
													head in. That was the only 
													time, because the door was 
													like that. I mean, I knew 
													how I’d left it. 
													 
													MO: It’s more that you know 
													I’d felt you’d done enough. 
													You’ve been and seen. It’s 
													quiet. 
													 
													G: Part of the reason we 
													ended up coming through the 
													back was the noise coming 
													through the front door. We 
													didn’t want to disturb them. 
													Sigh. Stupid, now, isn’t it. 
													 
													Voice over: It is possible 
													that JT is not the only 
													person who saw M being 
													carried away by the 
													abductor. 40 minutes after 
													J(T)’s sighting and ½ mile 
													away from the Mc’s apartment 
													a family also saw a man 
													carrying a young girl away 
													from the town. Later the 
													witness thought that this 
													might have been GM. But, 
													this was investigated and 
													ruled out by the Portuguese 
													police. 
													 
													DE: A man was seen here 
													carrying a child, just 
													before 10 pm on the night M 
													was abducted. When the man 
													saw the family he appeared 
													furtive and veered off to 
													one side and carried on 
													walking. Obviously, anyone 
													carrying a child at night, 
													it’s really important. We 
													need to find out who this 
													person was. 
													 
													Family Witness Statement: I 
													was with my family. We’d 
													been out for the night and 
													we were walking up the 
													street when I saw a man and 
													he was carrying a child. I 
													thought they were father and 
													daughter, so I wasn’t so 
													suspicious. The girl was 
													about 4, she looked like my 
													granddaughter, blonde hair, 
													pale white skin, typically 
													British. The man didn’t look 
													like a tourist. I can’t 
													explain why. It was, 
													probably, from his clothes. 
													 
													G: Someone knows the 
													information and someone 
													knows who took M and someone 
													knows where she is. Let’s 
													get moving! Let’s get the 
													phone ringing. 
													 
													Voice over: At home K is 
													preparing for the inevitable 
													media attention that will 
													surround the second 
													anniversary of M’s 
													disappearance. 
													 
													K: ( Showing photo album) 
													well this one. I think is 
													really sweet and it’s M just 
													when she arrived home from 
													hospital, erm, to our house. 
													I think she looks quite 
													cute, wrapped up in a little 
													bundle. She’s got those 
													eyes. I tell you, those eyes 
													that never closed. 
													 
													For us they’re not just 
													photos and especially now, 
													not having M in our life, 
													they’re more than photos and 
													to me, each photo is very 
													special. I mean, it’s M and 
													we’ve given out so much of 
													our daughter to the world 
													really. You know, you just 
													want to be able to retain 
													some of it. 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: Are we 
													allowed to see this one? 
													 
													K: uh-hum (nods head in 
													agreement) 
													 
													Voice of Interviewer: Do you 
													still feel her physically, 
													as much as you did? 
													 
													K: Tut… well, I know the M 
													that I know, you know. I 
													don’t know M at, you know, 
													nearly six. She might look 
													different. She could be 
													speaking a different 
													language (Scene shows her 
													packing for trip to States) 
													She might have her hair 
													different, she might have 
													different interests, but, 
													you know, she’s still our 
													daughter. 
													 
													G: (holding up a suit). I 
													think that’s pretty 
													business-like isn’t it? 
													 
													K: Yes 
													 
													G: Right, put that away 
													 
													Voice over: K&G are 
													preparing for a trip to 
													America that they hope will 
													breathe new life into the 
													search for M. As well as an 
													interview on the OW show, 
													they plan on visiting the 
													world’s leading child 
													recovery experts, who are 
													creating an image of M aged 
													six. 
													 
													K: We’re going to America 
													tomorrow and initially, 
													we’re going to Washington to 
													the NCMEC  
													 
													EA: Circulating the 
													photograph of, er, of a 
													child, who was not quite 
													four, two year’s later is 
													not good enough. 
													 
													When, we started this 10 
													year’s ago. The goal was to 
													use technology, er, to keep 
													these cases alive. To 
													provide new hope for parents 
													and new leads for law 
													enforcement and we said at 
													the time, wouldn’t it be 
													great if we could actually 
													find one of these kids and 
													we found 900 of them. Er, 
													everyone of these 900 cases, 
													the child had been missing 
													at least two years. So, what 
													we’ve tried to do is to take 
													your photos, er, as a guide. 
													Young children’s faces 
													change very quickly. As you 
													can see, she has her 
													mother’s jawline. She has 
													her mother’s mouth. It’s 
													striking. She has her 
													mother’s dimples. 
													 
													K: That’s me, as well, isn’t 
													it? (referring to picture of 
													her as a child) 
													 
													EA: This is you, as well. 
													Exactly. 
													 
													K laughs 
													 
													EA: But G, she has your 
													nose. 
													 
													G: The genes mix quite well. 
													(Both laughing). 
													 
													EA: They really do. They 
													really do. I mean it’s a 
													remarkable example of the 
													best of genetics. So, 
													leaning heavily, on 
													heredity, and using every 
													tool we can find, we truly 
													believe that this is what MM 
													looks like today and we hope 
													that somebody, that millions 
													of somebodies will look at 
													the picture, but, that 
													somebody will be moved to 
													reach out and say, I think I 
													have information. 
													 
													G: I glanced It’s a 
													different child and that is 
													really important. It’s not 
													the four year old or nearly 
													four year old little girl 
													and it’s hard, because, In 
													our memory, we remember her 
													the last day she was in 
													Portugal and what she looked 
													like, so… 
													 
													K: It’s a very emotional 
													thing, really, to see my 
													daughter in a different way 
													to how I remember her. Erm, 
													so if I’m honest, initially, 
													I, was quite upsetting and 
													then I started to look at 
													features and I thought, 
													well, that’s definitely M 
													and that bits M and, you 
													know, yes, she is 2 year’s 
													older. 
													 
													EA: Despite the love and the 
													care you that you put into 
													raising her, at that age, M 
													may not know she’s missing. 
													M may have been told, well, 
													now you are supposed to come 
													with me. So, we hope that 
													other children will look at 
													this. It’s not inconceivable 
													that she’s in a classroom 
													somewhere. The goal here is 
													to reach out to people 
													around the world and say. 
													Somebody knows something and 
													if you do, call us. 
													 
													Voice over: K&G now need to 
													publicise this new image. 
													The first step is to travel 
													from Washington to Chicago 
													for an interview on OWS, 
													that will be broadcast in 
													144 countries. 
													 
													G: It’s really important we 
													get this image out, as far 
													and as wide as possible. 
													Because, ultimately, we 
													don’t know where M is and if 
													she was moved out of 
													Portugal quickly, she could 
													be anywhere and that’s the 
													main reason for doing O(W) 
													get that image out there 
													 
													K: Nervous, but, it’s like 
													anything we’ve done, you 
													know, we’re doing it for a 
													reason and the reason’s to 
													held find M so just get on 
													with it. 
													 
													G: I actually think there’s 
													not much more else we can do 
													right now. 
													 
													K: I think we’ve achieved a 
													lot in the last few weeks 
													and we’re really hoping that 
													somebody who has been 
													sitting there, knowing 
													something, will suddenly 
													feel the courage and 
													compassion really to come 
													forward and of course, we’ve 
													also released the age 
													progression image of M, now 
													age 6 and I think that’s 
													important. Because that’s 
													almost appealing to people, 
													who may know M, whatever M’s 
													called now 
													 
													K: So I feel, we’ve all 
													worked really hard. I think 
													what we’ve done is positive 
													and productive. I actually 
													feel the chance of us 
													finding M is higher now, 
													it’s more likely to yield a 
													result and I actually feel a 
													little excited, really, 
													about what we’ve just done 
													so. 
													 
													G: I think it’s like, we 
													want it out there, now. All 
													the work’s been done and 
													it’s all being co-ordinated 
													round the anniversary. But 
													we want it out and it’s 
													just, let’s get moving. 
													 
													K: We just need that one 
													person, there might be more 
													than one person, but one 
													person to come forward and 
													say I’ve seen that girl or I 
													remember something from that 
													night and that could unravel 
													the whole thing. | 
												 
												 
									 | 
								 
							 
						 
									 | 
								 
							 
									 | 
									 
									
										| 
										 
										
										   | 
									 
								 
							 
							 |